Quick Book Review: A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens (DNF)
December 29, 2012 29 Comments
Caroline at Beauty is a Sleeping Cat and Delia at Postcards from Asia are organising the Dickens in December event. There is a read-a-long, a watch-a-long and there are of course book reviews.
***
After A Christmas Carol, which I really enjoyed, I tried A Tale of Two Cities, which I enjoyed at first, but later found extremely uninteresting.
The back of my book says: “A Tale of Two Cities (1859), Dickens’ greatest historical novel, traces the private lives of a group of people caught up in the cataclysms of the French Revolution and the Terror. Dickens based his historical details on Carlyle’s great work – The French Revolution – and also on his own observations and investigations during his numerous visits to Paris.”
I should have read that first. I just thought “Here’s a book by Dickens I haven’t read, let’s try it.” I have enjoyed some of his other novels, Oliver Twist, Nicholas Nickleby, A Christmas Carol, and one or two others, and I enjoyed those very much.
I did not finish A Tale of Two Cities and I think my main problem is the main topic: the French Revolution and the complots etc. They did not interest me. I enjoyed the beginning where an English gentleman is rescued after many years from a lowly French establishment (Book 1). This was fun. But then it continued with some different characters, I lost track a little, and I didn’t find anything in the story that made me want to read on.
A pity, but it’s just one of those things. Maybe I’d enjoy the book if I read it at a different time, and maybe I will re-try sometime. For now, a did-not-finish (after 120 pages).
Rating: did not finish
Number of pages: 321 (I read until page 120)
First published: 1859
I got this book: bought
Genre: classic
Have you read this book?
Did you enjoy it?
About Leeswammes
I totally agree with you, Judith. For me this wasn’t a story, it was a (boring) record of events that didn’t interest me.
Glad we agree on this one, Nadine. It’s not just me, then.
I’m sorry you didn’t like it but I thnk I get why. I never really understood why he chose this as his topic. I think it’s a love or hate book. I saw many who said they hated it and others love it. I know it will be one of the lasts I will try by him.
Caroline, thanks for explaining. I do believe in love or hate books. Maybe in another life time I will enjoy it, though.
I still haven’t read my festive Dickens book, oops. Well at least I have it ready for next year! This one holds no interest for me but I love Great Expectations and highly recommend it if you haven’t read it already.
Ellie, I haven’t read *Great Expectations*, so thanks for recommending it. That’s quite a different type of book, isn’t it?
What am I saying? I didn’t READ GE, but I watched the movie (DVD) just last week. Just forgot what it was called, I guess. It was really, really good.
It’s a shame you did not enjoy this. Once I got accustomed to the long sentences I loved it.
Jo, I didn’t mind the long sentences (although I do think Dickens is a little wordy at the best of times), but more the story. It was not for me. Glad you enjoyed it!
I have never read this one but have wanted to…. thanks for the heads up. 🙂
Maybe you’ll like it better than me, Sheila.
Sorry to hear you did not like A Tale of Two Cities. I love the book. It’s my favorite Dickens this far & only one I’ve read twice. 🙂 I think it is a very clever story, but that is revealed only in the end. 🙂 However, I do understand why you did not like it. It is different from his other novels.
I love A Christmas Carol, the book and the many film versions, but I doubt I could stay interested in this one. At 120 pages, you did pretty good!
I haven’t read any Dickens, but I think you did a good job reading til after 100 to decide to stop. I always give myself 100 pages before DNF’ing.
I strongly disliked this book when we had to read it in the 10th grade but decided to read it this year, 20+ years later and now that I’ve read a few more Dickens novels. I appreciated it much more but I can’t say I loved it. The subject is definitely hard going and the plots are sometimes hard to follow. I’m always surprised when someone says they love it. It’s nothing as good as David Copperfield or Great Expectations or Bleak House.
Kristen, well done for reading the whole thing! I’m sure I will one day. Just not yet.
Pingback: Dickens in December – Wrap up « Beauty is a Sleeping Cat
I have made it into my 50s and managed to avoid this book, so I understand! I loved Bleak House but never got back to reading any Dickens after that until I listened to David Copperfield on audio recently. Next on my Dickens list is Great Expectations! (My teachers must have assigned weird books because I never had to read this one in school either.)
Laurie, I’m sure there is no need to read the book. I do like Dickens, generally, but obviously not this one. I LOVED the movie of Great Expectations (actually a 3-part BBC series). Hope you’ll enjoy the book.
Sorry to hear you didn’t like it Judith. I do want to try this one soon, after Great Expectation that is.
As long as your expectations (!) are not of a standard Dickens, Jo.
I guess I’m in the minority. This is my favorite Dickens book, and I have read it twice. It took about 50 or so pages to get into, but I absolutely loved it! And the movie–the made for TV movie, that is–always get to me. I am a historical fiction fan so maybe that’s why I love this so much.
Ruth, funny how people can differ, isn’t it? I did like the beginning but started disliking it with the law suit and it went down from there for me. Maybe I should watch the movie.
I first read this book in high school (man years ago 🙂 ), but I’ve revisited it many times since. A Tale of Two Cities is one of my favorite books of all time, although as I recall, it did take until somewhere in the middle of the book before I was truly hooked the first time. I’d encourage you to keep going, although recognizing that it might just be a matter of taste. Still, I found the writing beautiful and was very moved by the story.
Lisa, I am planning to try again so time, I haven’t written it off completely. It’s nice to read that this is a favorite of yours!
Sorry to hear this book didn’t work for you. This is one of my favorites of Dickens, but it could also be because I tend to love books set during the French Revolution.
Nish, some people seem to love it, others hate it. I have no particular interest in the French revolution so that didn’t help either.
Well, don’t give up totally on this one! I suggest (and yep, brace yourself…this is a sacrilege I know…:) ) but check out the movie version. Yes, it’s from 1980, but you will at least kw how it ends….and the ending is so redeeming! It brought tears to my eyes, and I am a terrible cynic! Ha! Sometimes, time is of the essence and Dickens does seem a bit wordy if you’re not into the plot heart and soul! Enjoy the suggested Netflix or YouTube experience! 😉
Thanks, Crystal. I watched two Dickens movies in December, which I absolutely loved, so this is a good idea.